Facebook
X
Pinterest
Copy Link
But here’s something buyers don’t always realize: getting $10,000 off the purchase price isn’t necessarily the same as getting $10,000 in seller concessions.
Depending on your loan, your cash available for closing, how long you plan to own the home, and current interest rates, you may get more immediate benefit from asking the seller to help with closing costs or an interest-rate buydown instead of simply lowering the price.
That’s especially worth understanding before you write an offer.
And like every part of the homebuying process, financing options and negotiations should be based on the property, loan qualifications, financial circumstances, and terms of the transaction—not on a buyer’s race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, national origin, or other characteristics protected by applicable fair housing laws.
Here’s how the three strategies work and what buyers should discuss with their lender before deciding which one makes the most sense.
First, What’s the Difference?
Let’s keep this simple.
A price reduction lowers what you’re paying for the house. If you’re financing the purchase, it may also reduce the amount you’re borrowing. That means a somewhat smaller monthly principal-and-interest payment and less interest paid over the life of the loan.
A seller credit keeps the negotiated purchase price in place but allows the seller to pay certain eligible buyer costs at closing, subject to the rules of the buyer’s loan program. This can reduce the amount of cash a buyer needs to bring to closing.
An interest-rate buydown uses funds—potentially including an allowable seller contribution—to reduce the buyer’s mortgage costs. A buydown can be temporary or permanent, depending on the structure and loan program.
The important point is that the same dollar amount can affect your finances very differently depending on how it’s used.
Why a Price Cut May Not Lower Your Payment as Much as You Expect
Suppose you’re negotiating and the seller is willing to give up $10,000.
As a buyer, it’s tempting to immediately say:
“Great. Take $10,000 off the price.”
That may absolutely be the right choice—but look at what happens first.
If you’re putting money down, a $10,000 reduction in purchase price does not necessarily reduce your mortgage balance by the entire $10,000 because your loan is generally based on a percentage of the purchase price.
Even when the full $10,000 does reduce the loan balance, the savings are then spread over potentially hundreds of monthly payments.
A seller credit, meanwhile, could potentially offset thousands of dollars you would otherwise need to bring to closing.
And using an allowable credit toward a buydown could have a more noticeable effect on your monthly payment.
That’s why I don’t love looking at concessions purely as:
“How much can we get off the house?”
The better question is:
“How can we structure this concession to provide the greatest benefit for this particular buyer?”
How a 2-1 Temporary Buydown Works
A 2-1 buydown is one of the better-known temporary buydown structures.
Imagine that your actual mortgage note rate is 7%.
A 2-1 structure could effectively make the principal-and-interest payment equivalent to:
Year 1: 5%
Year 2: 6%
Year 3 and beyond: 7%
The mortgage itself hasn’t magically become a 5% loan. Funds placed into a buydown account subsidize the difference in payments during the temporary period.
Freddie Mac, for example, allows qualifying temporary subsidy buydowns and requires borrowers on fixed-rate mortgages to qualify based on the full note rate, not the temporarily reduced payment.
That last part is important.
You Still Need to Be Comfortable With the Full Payment
I would never suggest looking at a 2-1 buydown and thinking:
“I’ll worry about year three later.”
You should evaluate the home based on the payment you’ll ultimately have—not just the discounted first-year payment.
A temporary buydown can provide valuable breathing room during the first couple of years of homeownership, but it doesn’t make an unaffordable home affordable.
That’s an important distinction.
What About a Permanent Rate Buydown?
This is where discount points enter the conversation.
Instead of temporarily subsidizing your payment, discount points are paid upfront to obtain a lower mortgage rate for the loan.
One discount point generally equals 1% of the loan amount, but there’s an important misconception here: one point does not automatically equal a specific reduction in your interest rate.
The rate improvement you receive for paying points changes with the lender, loan product, pricing and market conditions.
So I would not rely on a rule such as “one point always lowers the rate by 0.25%.”
Ask your lender for an actual side-by-side quote instead.
For example:
Option A: No points at Rate X
Option B: $5,000 in points at Rate Y
Option C: $10,000 in points at Rate Z
Then calculate how long it takes the monthly savings to recover the upfront cost.
That’s your break-even period.
If it costs $8,000 to permanently reduce your rate and that saves you $200 per month:
$8,000 ÷ $200 = 40 months
You’d reach the simple break-even point in approximately 3 years and 4 months.
If you’re reasonably confident you’ll keep that mortgage considerably longer than 40 months, the permanent buydown becomes more interesting.
If you expect to sell or refinance much sooner, paying for that permanent rate reduction may provide less value.
When a Seller Credit Can Be More Valuable Than a Price Reduction
Seller credits can be especially useful for buyers who have enough income to comfortably afford the mortgage but want to preserve cash.
Buying a house comes with more upfront expenses than just the down payment.
Depending on the transaction, you may have lender fees, title and escrow costs, prepaid property taxes, homeowners insurance, inspections, moving expenses and the inevitable list of things you discover you need after getting the keys.
Using an allowable seller credit for eligible closing costs could leave more of your own savings intact.
That cash reserve can be extremely valuable after closing.
There is an important catch, though: you can’t simply ask for an unlimited seller credit.
Loan programs have rules governing how much a seller or other interested party may contribute and how those funds can be used.
For example, current Fannie Mae rules for a principal residence or second home generally permit financing concessions of up to 3% when LTV/CLTV exceeds 90%, 6% from 75.01%–90%, and 9% at 75% or below. The rules also limit those concessions to eligible costs, and seller-funded temporary or permanent rate buydowns count toward the applicable contribution limit.
So this is absolutely something to run by your lender before putting a specific credit into your offer.
When I’d Consider Asking for a Price Reduction Instead
Seller credits and buydowns aren’t automatically better.
There are plenty of situations where lowering the purchase price could make more sense.
For example, if comparable sales don’t support the asking price, the bigger issue may be the home’s value—not the mortgage payment.
A lower price could also make sense when you’re primarily concerned with the amount you’re paying for the property rather than preserving cash at closing.
And remember that concessions can also matter in an appraisal. Fannie Mae instructs appraisers to consider sales and financing concessions when analyzing comparable transactions and their potential effect on sales prices.
So none of these strategies exists in a vacuum.
When Should You Ask a Seller for a Credit?
This is where local market conditions really matter.
If a home has been sitting on the market, has already had a price reduction, or the seller otherwise appears open to negotiating, asking for a credit could be worth exploring.
But if you’re competing against several strong offers, asking the seller to contribute toward your costs could make your offer less attractive.
That’s why I’d rather determine the strategy property by property than decide beforehand that every offer needs a seller credit.
A home that’s been sitting for three weeks can require a completely different strategy from a new listing with multiple interested buyers.
Compare the Options Before You Write the Offer
This is probably the most useful takeaway.
Before negotiating a significant seller concession, ask your lender to run the numbers.
Have them show you something like:
| Option | Purchase Price | Cash to Close | Mortgage Rate | Monthly P&I | Buydown Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original terms | — | — | — | — | — |
| Price reduction | — | — | — | — | — |
| Seller closing-cost credit | — | — | — | — | — |
| Temporary buydown | — | — | — | — | — |
| Permanent buydown | — | — | — | — | — |
Then you’re not guessing.
You’re comparing the actual effect on your cash, your monthly payment and your long-term cost.
The Bottom Line
When a seller is willing to negotiate, don’t automatically assume the best answer is lowering the purchase price.
Sometimes it will be.
Other times, using an allowable seller credit to reduce closing costs or fund an interest-rate buydown could provide substantially more immediate financial benefit.
The best option depends on your mortgage, down payment, available cash, expected ownership timeline and long-term financial goals.
That’s why one of the best things a buyer can do is get the lender and real estate agent talking before the offer is written.
If you’re considering buying in San Jose or Santa Clara County, I’d be happy to help you look at the market, identify where sellers may have more room to negotiate, and build an offer strategy around your priorities.
This article is for general educational purposes and isn’t financial, tax or legal advice. Mortgage rates, discount-point pricing, seller-contribution limits and loan guidelines can change. Confirm the current terms and calculations for your specific loan directly with your lender.
GET YOUR FREE HOME SELLING BOOK
About the Author – Michelle Elliott
With over 20 years of experience navigating the fast-paced Silicon Valley market, I provide a strategic, results-driven approach to residential real estate. My career is built on a foundation of deep local expertise and a relentless commitment to my clients’ success, resulting in over $235 million in lifetime sales volume and a consistent ranking in the top 3% of agents in Santa Clara County and top 2% at Coldwell Banker. My expertise has been featured on KTVU Fox 2, Real Producers and the Willow Glen Resident. She is also the co-host of the San Jose Podcast “Say What You Want About Real Estate”
A Hyper-Local Expert with Global Reach
I specialize in San Jose, in the neighborhoods of Willow Glen (95125 & 95124) Cambrian Park and Almaden, Downtown San Jose/Japantown (95112) markets. As a certified Luxury Property Specialist with Coldwell Banker Realty, I combine high-end marketing strategies with granular neighborhood knowledge to help my clients achieve premium results.
The “Tiger” at the Negotiating Table
My clients have characterized me as a “tiger” at the negotiating table who remains “sweet and patient” with my clients throughout the process. I pride myself on being a fierce advocate for my buyers and sellers, ensuring the best possible terms in every transaction, and I strive to be the best Realtor in 95125! This balance, drive, and tenacity have earned me consistent 5-star ratings across Google, Zillow, Realtor.com, and Yelp.
Michelle Elliott
Michelle@michelleelliottrealtor.com
1712 Meridian Ave, Ste C, San Jose, CA
DRE 01777533
