Facebook
X
Pinterest
Copy Link
If you’re planning a move but aren’t sure selling is the right choice, renting out your current home may be worth considering.
Some homeowners decide to keep their property as a long-term investment. Others aren’t ready to sell in today’s market or simply want more flexibility before making a permanent decision.
While renting can offer financial benefits, it also comes with responsibilities and costs that are easy to overlook. Before you decide, here are a few important things to consider.
Start With the Numbers
The first question isn’t, “Will the rent cover my mortgage?”
It’s whether the property makes financial sense as a rental after all of the expenses are factored in.
Be sure to account for:
- Your monthly mortgage payment, property taxes, homeowners insurance, and HOA dues (if applicable).
- Vacancy periods between tenants.
- Ongoing maintenance and unexpected repairs.
- Property management fees if you don’t plan to manage the home yourself.
- A landlord insurance policy, which is different from a standard homeowner’s policy.
If the numbers still work after accounting for these costs, renting may be a good option. If you’ll be contributing money each month with no clear long-term strategy, selling may deserve another look.
Learn How Local Rental Rules Apply to Your Property
Before listing your home for rent, take time to understand the local and state regulations that may apply.
Depending on the property’s age, type, and number of units, your home may be subject to California’s statewide tenant protection laws, local rent stabilization rules, or both.
Because these regulations can change, it’s important to verify how they apply to your specific property before advertising it for rent or signing a lease. The City of San Jose’s Rent Stabilization Program is a good place to start, and a local real estate attorney can help answer legal questions.
Will You Manage the Property Yourself?
Some homeowners enjoy managing their own rental properties, while others prefer hiring a professional.
Managing the property yourself may save money, but it also means you’ll be responsible for:
- Marketing the property
- Responding to maintenance requests
- Coordinating repairs
- Screening applicants
- Staying current on landlord-tenant laws and local regulations
If you’ve already moved away from the area—or simply don’t want the day-to-day responsibilities—a professional property manager can handle much of the work on your behalf.
Have a Consistent Screening Process
Finding a qualified tenant is one of the most important parts of being a landlord.
Many property owners verify income, review credit and rental history, and contact previous housing references as part of their application process.
Whatever criteria you choose, apply the same standards consistently to every applicant and comply with all applicable fair housing laws.
Think About Your Long-Term Plans
It’s also worth considering what you may want to do with the property a few years from now.
For example:
- If you plan to sell later, renting the property could affect the tax treatment of your future sale. A tax professional can explain how the rules apply to your situation.
- Selling a tenant-occupied property may require additional planning depending on the lease agreement and applicable notice requirements.
- If you hope to keep the property as a long-term investment, think about whether you’re prepared for the ongoing responsibilities that come with being a landlord.
Looking ahead now can help you avoid surprises later.
The Bottom Line
Renting out your San Jose home can be a smart financial move—but it should be approached like any other investment decision.
Take time to evaluate the numbers, understand the rules that apply to your property, decide how you want to manage it, and think about your long-term goals before making a decision.
If you’re trying to decide whether selling or renting makes more sense, I’d be happy to help you compare both options based on your property’s current value, potential rental income, and your overall goals. Having all the information upfront can make the decision much easier.
Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational purposes only and should not be considered legal, tax, or financial advice. Rental laws, tenant protections, and local regulations can change over time. Always consult the City of San Jose, a qualified real estate attorney, tax professional, or other appropriate advisor regarding your specific situation before renting out your property.
GET YOUR FREE HOME SELLING BOOK
About the Author – Michelle Elliott
With over 20 years of experience navigating the fast-paced Silicon Valley market, I provide a strategic, results-driven approach to residential real estate. My career is built on a foundation of deep local expertise and a relentless commitment to my clients’ success, resulting in over $235 million in lifetime sales volume and a consistent ranking in the top 3% of agents in Santa Clara County and top 2% at Coldwell Banker. My expertise has been featured on KTVU Fox 2, Real Producers and the Willow Glen Resident. She is also the co-host of the San Jose Podcast “Say What You Want About Real Estate”
A Hyper-Local Expert with Global Reach
I specialize in San Jose, in the neighborhoods of Willow Glen (95125 & 95124) Cambrian Park and Almaden, Downtown San Jose/Japantown (95112) markets. As a certified Luxury Property Specialist with Coldwell Banker Realty, I combine high-end marketing strategies with granular neighborhood knowledge to help my clients achieve premium results.
The “Tiger” at the Negotiating Table
My clients have characterized me as a “tiger” at the negotiating table who remains “sweet and patient” with my clients throughout the process. I pride myself on being a fierce advocate for my buyers and sellers, ensuring the best possible terms in every transaction, and I strive to be the best Realtor in 95125! This balance, drive, and tenacity have earned me consistent 5-star ratings across Google, Zillow, Realtor.com, and Yelp.
Michelle Elliott
Michelle@michelleelliottrealtor.com
1712 Meridian Ave, Ste C, San Jose, CA
DRE 01777533
